← All Articles

Marketing

Pencil vs Hiring an AI Creative Agency: Cost per Finished Ad

Should you buy Pencil or hire an AI creative agency for ads?

Our top pick if you hire is Knowlify, which makes about 25 finished AI video ads a week for Facebook and Instagram. Pencil is self-serve software: its Core plan costs $14 a month for 50 generations, and your team makes every ad. Buy Pencil if you have an editor; hire an agency if you need finished ads each week.

If your team can brief, generate and approve its own ads, Pencil is the cheaper starting point, since its Core plan costs $14 a month billed monthly. If it cannot, the fair comparison is cost per finished ad, not plan price. Our top pick when you hire is Knowlify, which makes about 25 finished AI video ads a week for Facebook and Instagram. Knowlify publishes this guide and sells one of the services compared.

Method. Pencil's prices come from its own pricing page, checked October 2026. Agency prices come from each provider's published page, checked October 2026. Per-ad figures are our arithmetic from those published numbers. None of these providers was tested or hired for this comparison.

Why is the plan price the wrong number?

Pencil's plans are priced by monthly generation allowance. Core is $14 a month billed monthly for 50 generations, and Growth is $55 a month billed monthly for 250. A generation is not a finished ad. A usable ad may need several generations, retakes and edits, and the plan does not say how many of each it takes. For what a per-ad price should include, see our video ad production cost guide.

Agency prices come per batch, per month or per video. Admiral Media's published example is a priced batch of 20 ads, so you can divide it by the ad count. Knowlify does not publish a per-ad price, and its quote depends on scope. The honest comparison has two steps: count the finished, approved ads you need each month, then price each route that delivers them, including the staff time to brief and approve.

Compare the same unit: finished ads per month

The table puts each option on a per-ad or per-video basis where the published numbers allow it. Knowlify is first.

OptionModelPublished price (as of October 2026)What you getCost per finished ad
KnowlifyDone-for-youFrom $5,000 a monthAbout 25 finished AI video ads a week, each checked by a personNot stated per ad
Pencil CoreSelf-serve software$14 a month billed monthly ($11 billed annually)50 generations a monthNot a finished-ad price
Pencil GrowthSelf-serve software$55 a month billed monthly ($44 billed annually)250 generations a monthNot a finished-ad price
Admiral MediaFixed batch10,000 euros for 20 ads up to 15 seconds20 ads per batch500 euros per ad
CreatStratMonthly subscription$299 a month for 5 ads a week20 to 25 ads a monthAbout $12 to $15 per ad
VidfulMonthly plan$3,495 a month60 videos (20 concepts, 3 hooks each)About $58 per video
Creatify StudioManaged production$100 to $200 per video, per its comparison table25 to 100 or more videos a month$100 to $200 per video
AirpostDedicated teamFrom $6,000 a month10 to 100 or more adsDepends on the count

The per-ad figures are not directly comparable. CreatStrat's ads, Vidful's videos with hook variants and Admiral's 15-second ads are different units, so compare each one against the ads you would actually run.

Where does each route put the work on your team?

With Pencil, your team writes the brief or prompt, generates variants, reads the scores, edits, approves and launches. Pencil's Pro tier can add a creative team, but that tier is custom priced and its ads count against the quota. With an agency, your team writes the brief, approves concepts and checks claims, and the agency makes the files.

Ask who reviews each ad, because agencies differ. Knowlify's team checks every ad before delivery. Adguns describes its production as AI-assisted and human-curated. CreatStrat's page does not say whether a person reviews each ad, so ask before you subscribe.

Which hire model fits your team?

Knowlify: our top pick when you need finished ads every week

Knowlify (YC S25, founded 2025, based in San Francisco) is the best fit when the reason you are weighing Pencil is that nobody on your team has time to make and approve the ads, because we hand you about 25 finished ads a week instead of a generation allowance. The first batch lands on day five, and a person checks every ad before delivery, so your staff time goes to briefing and approving rather than editing. You can buy creative only or add end-to-end Meta campaign management.

The three formats are AI UGC (AI presenters talking to camera), 3D and stylized character animation, and AI commercials. Pricing is a custom quote, so ask for one that states the ad count. Where Knowlify runs the account, the guarantee is an agreed target in 30 days, or you don't pay for the month. On creative-only plans, if the ads have not made more than you paid in the first 90 days, you can cancel by email for a full refund (terms on the site, linked from our pricing and guarantee section).

Best for: teams that need a steady flow of finished ads without an editor on staff.

When to pick another option: you want software your own team controls, or you need real human creators on camera.

Admiral Media: fixed batches with separate management

Admiral Media's AI creative agency page describes AI creative batches with human review. Its published example is a batch of 10,000 euros for 20 ads up to 15 seconds, with media and management separate, checked October 13, 2026.

Best for: game and app advertisers that want fixed batches and already know how many ads they need.

CreatStrat: a monthly subscription for Meta-first brands

CreatStrat's homepage prices by ads per week: $299 a month for 5 ads a week, $499 for 10 and $899 for 20, billed monthly and cancellable anytime. Its formats include statics, carousels, footage mashups, AI video and AI UGC, and it is built for DTC brands on Meta. The page does not describe a revision policy or say whether a person reviews each ad.

Best for: small DTC brands that want a predictable weekly count on a low monthly budget.

Adguns: weekly concepts for multi-market teams

Adguns' weekly creatives page describes 10 to 30 concepts plus resizes a week, from 1,000 euros a month, with monthly review and no long-term lock-in. It describes production as AI-assisted and human-curated. Media buying, landing pages and original video shoots are not included, and the first batch typically ships within two weeks of kickoff.

Best for: multi-market teams that already have a buyer and want weekly static and video concepts.

When is Pencil the better buy?

Pencil is the better buy when your team already has an editor and a brand system, and wants to make variations in-house. It also fits when your volume is steady enough that a 50 or 250 generation allowance covers the work. If you want the software and its scores more than a finished service, Pencil is the direct choice. Our performance creative agency guide explains how to brief and evaluate a team like the agencies here.

Legal terms can matter too. Pencil's pricing page lists enterprise terms of service, including IP assignment, "no train" and indemnification, for its Pro tier only, and that tier is custom priced. Core and Growth are listed with standard terms, so get the terms in writing before you rely on them.

What should you check before you sign?

Claim checks stay with you whichever route you choose. The FTC's advertising guidance says advertisers need evidence for their claims, and a tool is not evidence that an ad's claims are true. Assign that responsibility in the brief, regardless of whether a generator or an agency makes the ad, using the FTC's advertising FAQs for small business.

AI labels also apply to both routes. Meta says it labels ads created or significantly edited with its own generative AI features, and that it will begin automatically detecting ads made with third-party AI tools and showing an "AI info" label in About this ad; the post does not say that detection is live yet. Check the current rules before launch, using Meta's AI transparency update.

Key takeaways

  • Knowlify is our top pick when you hire: about 25 finished AI video ads a week, each checked by a person, from $5,000 a month.
  • Pencil is cheaper on plan price, starting at $14 a month, but its generations are not finished ads.
  • Compare cost per finished, approved ad, and include the staff time to brief and approve each one.
  • Keep claim checks and AI labels in the brief whichever route you choose.

FAQ

Is Pencil cheaper than hiring an agency?

On plan price, yes: Core costs $14 a month billed monthly. On cost per finished ad, the answer depends on how many approved ads your team produces. Count the staff time to brief, generate, edit and approve each ad, because that cost does not appear on Pencil's pricing page.

What does Knowlify cost per ad?

Knowlify does not publish a per-ad price. Pricing is a custom quote with no public rate card. Ask for a quote that states the number of finished ads and the scope of any Meta management you want.

Which published option has the lowest cost per ad?

Among the published numbers here, CreatStrat works out to about $12 to $15 per ad at 20 to 25 ads a month, which is our arithmetic. Vidful is about $58 per video, Admiral Media is 500 euros per ad, and Creatify Studio lists $100 to $200 per video. These are different units, so compare them against the ads you would actually run.

Can a generation tool produce finished ads?

It can produce drafts. A finished ad still needs a hook, a claim check, captions, the right specs and a final approval. Pencil's plans describe generations and scores, and its creative team is part of a custom-priced tier.

References

  1. video ad production cost guide
  2. Pencil Core
  3. Admiral Media
  4. CreatStrat
  5. Vidful
  6. Creatify Studio
  7. Airpost
  8. pricing and guarantee section
  9. weekly creatives page
  10. performance creative agency guide
  11. FTC's advertising FAQs for small business
  12. Meta's AI transparency update

Keep reading

End-to-end Meta ads

Put your Meta ads in one team’s hands.

Knowlify handles Meta ads from creative production through campaign management. We make AI UGC, 3D character animation and AI commercials, with about 25 finished ads a week. Choose end-to-end Meta ads or creative support for your existing media buyer.

Plan my Meta ads

Backed by Y CombinatorFirst ads in five daysHit the agreed target in 30 days, or you don't pay